Carvana Co. (CVNA)

NYSE · Tempe, Arizona, USA · Founded 2012 · CEO Ernie Garcia III

Valuation summary

$45.20 fair value versus $68.00 in the market, a difference of -33.5%. Rated Sell.

Fair value per share$45.20
Current share price$68.00
Upside / downside-33.5%
Bear case$18.53
Bull case$84.24
Discount rate (WACC)13.4%
Terminal growth3.00%
Market capitalisation$75B
EV / Sales1.9x

About Carvana Co.

Founded in 2012 by Ernie Garcia III, whose father's company DriveTime is a large used-car dealer. Garcia is chief executive. Carvana sells used cars entirely online, delivering them to customers' homes or through its multi-storey car vending machines, and finances many of them through loans it then sells to investors. It bought the US physical auction business of ADESA in 2022, giving it reconditioning capacity across the country. After nearly collapsing under debt in 2022, it restructured, turned profitable and is now one of the fastest-growing retailers in the United States.

Investment case

  • Unit sales are growing quickly in a large, fragmented market where it has less than a few percent share.
  • Profit per car is well above traditional dealers thanks to centralised reconditioning and finance.
  • The ADESA network gives it capacity to keep growing without large new investment.

Key risks

  • Profits rely heavily on selling the car loans it originates, which depends on credit markets.
  • A large debt load remains from its earlier near-collapse.
  • Accounting and related-party questions with DriveTime have drawn short-seller criticism.

Recent developments

Revenue by segment

Retail vehicle sales70%
Wholesale vehicles18%
Other (finance, warranties)12%

Five-year forecast

RevenueFree cash flow
Year 1$59.3B$2.4B
Year 2$81.4B$3.2B
Year 3$105.4B$4.1B
Year 4$128.1B$5.0B
Year 5$145.8B$5.6B

What the street says

One of the most dramatic turnarounds of the decade; the debate is whether its loan-sale profits are as durable as its unit growth.

Comparable companies: TM · NIO · HMC · TSLA · XPEV · RACE · F · CPRT

Open the interactive model, price chart and sensitivity grid →