The Progressive Corporation (PGR)
NYSE · Mayfield Village, Ohio, USA · Founded 1937 · CEO Tricia Griffith
Valuation summary
$140.83 fair value versus $229.96 in the market, a difference of -38.8%. Rated Sell.
| Fair value per share | $140.83 |
| Current share price | $229.96 |
| Upside / downside | -38.8% |
| Bear case | $61.92 |
| Bull case | $266.33 |
| Discount rate (WACC) | 9.4% |
| Terminal growth | 2.60% |
| Market capitalisation | $133B |
| EV / Sales | 1.5x |
About The Progressive Corporation
Founded in 1937 by Joseph Lewis and Jack Green, initially insuring drivers other companies rejected. Tricia Griffith has been CEO since 2016. Progressive is one of the largest US auto insurers and has been taking share consistently for years. Its advantage is pricing sophistication — segmenting drivers more finely than competitors, and using telematics through the Snapshot programme to price on actual driving behaviour rather than demographic proxies.
Investment case
- Consistently better underwriting results than the industry, reflected in a combined ratio below 100 in most years.
- Direct distribution avoids agent commissions and structurally lowers the cost base.
- Telematics data advantage compounds — more driving data means better pricing means better risk selection.
Key risks
- Auto insurance is cyclical: periods of strong profitability attract competition and pricing softens.
- Severe weather and catastrophe losses hit the property segment hard.
- Rate increases that restored profitability may now slow policy growth.
Recent developments
- 2026-10-14 · Q3 EPS of $4.60 beats estimates as net premiums written rise 4% to $22.3bn and the combined ratio improves to 88.7 source
- 2026-09-18 · August net income fell 22% to $951m and combined ratio rose to 89.3 from 83.1; premiums written up 6%, policies in force up 7% source
Revenue by segment
| Personal Auto | 73% |
| Commercial Lines | 15% |
| Property | 12% |
Five-year forecast
| Revenue | Free cash flow | |
|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $98.3B | $3.4B |
| Year 2 | $105.8B | $3.9B |
| Year 3 | $113.9B | $4.5B |
| Year 4 | $122.7B | $5.1B |
| Year 5 | $132.1B | $5.8B |
What the street says
Widely admired as the best operator in personal auto insurance. Monthly results through August 2026 showed earnings falling year on year, with the August combined ratio at 89.3 against 83.1 a year earlier while policies in force still grew 7%. The question is where the cycle is, not whether the company executes.
Comparable companies: MFC · CB · AXP · ALL · TRV · MS · MET · BN
Open the interactive model, price chart and sensitivity grid →